11 Best Pistol Magazine Pouches for Concealed Carry in 2024

Last update:
We are reader supported! We participate in affiliate programs and we may be compensated (at no cost to you) when you use our links and make a purchase.

We tested over 30 magazine pouches and selected the top 11 for concealed carry. Our top picks are the Alien Gear Photon Mag Carrier and the Stealth Gear Ultralight Mag Carrier.

For this review, we focused on concealed carry. There are many magazine pouches out there. However, if you’re looking for one for concealed carry, you’re going to need something different than if you were buying one for the range.

Best Pistol Magazine Pouch
Six of the magazine pouches that Jason tested
Some of our favorite magazine pouches

Our team has over 25 years of experience using magazine pouches for concealed carry, the military, and pistol competitions. We have accumulated a bunch of them and have been testing them for years.

What makes a concealed carry mag pouch different from the other common ones?

Keep reading to find out.


Quick Summary of Our Favorite Pistol Mag Pouches

BEST OVERALL
Alien Gear Photon Magazine Carrier

Alien Gear Photon Mag Carrier

IWB or OWB

Polymer Material

Adjustable

MSRP: $25

BEST LEATHER
Craft Leather Single Mag Pouch

Craft Leather Single Mag Pouch

IWB or OWB

Leather

Not Adjustable

MSRP: $45

BEST VALUE
CYA Supply Magazine Pouch

CYA Supply Mag Carrier

IWB or OWB

Polymer

Adjustable

MSRP: $19.97

BEST IWB
Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Magazine Carrier

Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Mag Carrier

IWB

Hybrid Design

Adjustable

MSRP: $49.95

BEST DOUBLE MAG
Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier

Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier

IWB or OWB

Hybrid Design

Adjustable

MSRP: $39.95


Best Pistol Magazine Pouches for Concealed Carry

To make this review easy to follow, I have split it up between single and double mag pouches. See our guide below to learn when you should consider a double over a single.

Best Single Magazine Pouches

Alien Gear Photon Magazine Carrier – Best Overall

Alien Gear Photon Magazine Carrier
  • Type: IWB or OWB
  • Material: Polymer
  • Sizes: 9mm/.40 Single or Double Stack
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $24.88

The Alien Gear Photon Mag Carrier is one of my favorite magazine pouches.

It can be worn IWB or OWB and also comes with a sidecar attachment to connect it to a Photon Holster for appendix carry.

The retention of the carrier is adjustable. I like how it has four screws around the carrier so I can set the retention just how I like.

Alien gear Photon Mag Carrier
My Alien Gear Photon Mag Carrier

I also like the belt clip. I have found some clips are hard to take on and off, especially when carrying them in the OWB position. This clip slides easily over my belt, and I can pull it at the bottom to remove it.

I can also adjust the angle of the belt clip, which you can’t usually do outside of competition mag carriers. The belt clip is wide, so it stays in place on my belt. It even comes with a spare belt clip and spare screws.

Jason wearing the Alien Gear Photon Mag Pouch
Wearing the Alien Gear Photon Mag pouch

This low-profile mag carrier conceals easily under my shirt when I wear it OWB. I can draw my magazine quickly in this position, and it is my preferred way to use it. When I wear it IWB, it pushes my mag against my body, making it harder to draw properly.

Recommended for:

The Alien Gear Photon Mag carrier is for anyone looking for a good all-around mag carrier. It is one of the best we have found and is also affordable.

PROS

Adjustability

Low Profile

Sturdy Clip

Price

CONS

IWB is not so Comfortable


Craft Holsters Single Magazine Pouch – Best Leather Mag Pouch

Craft Holsters Single Magazine Pouch
  • Type: IWB or OWB
  • Material: Leather
  • Sizes: Custom-made for hundreds of gun models
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $45

The Craft Holsters Single Magazine Pouch is a leather mag pouch that works surprisingly well.

I have not paid much attention to leather magazine pouches in the past, mostly because they are usually bulky and hard to conceal.

That changed when I tried this one. It is surprisingly compact, one of the most compact mag pouches I have ever used.

Craft Leather single mag pouch
My Craft Holsters Leather single mag pouch

The Italian leather is top-notch and looks great. The metal spring steel clip is held onto the pouch with a reinforced layer of leather and riveted as well.

While the magazine retention is not adjustable, the pouch is custom-made for my magazine. I can say they fit perfectly, and I don’t need to adjust anything.

Jason wearing the Craft leather single mag pouch
Wearing the Craft leather single mag pouch

I prefer to wear it OWB even with just a T-shirt. It is low profile, so it is easy to conceal. IWB works as well, but it pushes the top of my mag too close to my body and makes it hard to draw properly.

Recommended for:

The Craft Holsters Single Magazine Pouch is for anyone who wants a low-profile, leather mag pouch. This one conceals easily.

PROS

Quality Leather

Custom Made

Sturdy Clip

CONS

Not Adjustable

Price


CYA Supply Magazine Pouch – Best Value

CYA Supply Magazine Pouch
  • Type: IWB or OWB
  • Material: Kydex
  • Sizes: 9mm – .45ACP, Single and Double Stack
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $19.97

The CYA Supply Mag Pouch is one of the most affordable on our list. But it is not “cheap” by any means.

I like that the magazine retention on this mag carrier is adjustable by two screws on the side. I can set it just how I want.

CYA Mag Carrier showing the clip
The back of the CYA Supply Mag carrier setup in OWB

To switch between IWB and OWB, the clip moves from the center of the carrier over to the adjustment screws. I found that this made it very low profile when wearing it IWB. But, since it pushes the top of the magazine against my body, I still prefer to wear it OWB.

If you want maximum concealment, this one in the IWB configuration is a good choice. Just keep in mind drawing the magazine will be harder than OWB.

Wearing the CYA Supply mag carrier in the OWB position
Wearing the CYA Supply Mag carrier OWB

The only thing I don’t like about this pouch is the clip. It is a little narrow, so it doesn’t stay in place as well as others. Also, it does not have a tab at the bottom. This makes it a little harder to take off the clip.

Recommended for:

The CYA Supply Magazine Pouch is for anyone looking for a very concealable mag carrier. This one is very affordable as well.

PROS

Concealability

Adjustable Retention

Price

CONS

Belt Clip


Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Magazine Carrier – Best IWB

Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Magazine Carrier
  • Type: IWB
  • Material: Leather and Kydex
  • Sizes: 9mm – .45, Single and Double Stack
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $49.95

The Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Mag Carrier is a hybrid design mag pouch similar to their holsters. This makes it one of the most comfortable ways to carry a magazine IWB.

The Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Magazine Carrier
The Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Magazine Carrier

The suede-lined Amish leather backing keeps the mag away from my body. This makes it very comfortable to carry and provides a sturdy surface to index my hand against when drawing the mag. When I carry other mag pouches IWB, the baseplate of the mag tends to press against my body, making it harder to draw.

I like that this mag pouch has a tuckable clip so that I can tuck my shirt around it. This makes it very concealable in dress clothes if I need to.

The magazine retention is adjustable, with five screws that I can adjust. It also includes hardware I can adjust between single and double-stack mags.

Wearing the Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Magazine Carrier
Wearing the Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Magazine Carrier

The only thing I don’t like about it is smaller 15-round mags like those for a Glock 19 or Walther PDP compact sit a little low in it. This makes it harder to get a good grip on them when drawing.

Recommended for:

The Hidden Hybrid Slim IWB Mag Carrier is for anyone who wants a comfortable IWB mag pouch that is very concealable.

PROS

Comfortable Hybrid Design

Single/Double Stack Convertible

Tuckable Clip

Adjustable Retention

CONS

Short Mags Sit Deep


Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier

Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier
  • Type: IWB or OWB
  • Material: Leather and Polymer
  • Sizes: 9mm – .45ACP, Single and Double Stack
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $33.95

The Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier is one of the most flexible mag carriers we have found.

I really like the adjustable retention. Instead of tightening screws that compress the shell, this mag carrier has a side retention device that applies pressure to the side of the mag. This allows me to carry almost any size mag that fits the carrier. I can adjust the set screw to get the retention that I want.

Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier setup OWB
Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier setup OWB

We used this mag carrier three ways. IWB without the leather backer, IWB with the leather backer, and OWB.

Using it IWB without the leather backer has the same issue as other IWB mag carriers. It pushes the top of the magazine into my body and makes it hard to draw quickly. I find I have to re-gripping the magazine after I draw. Plus, it is not exactly the most comfortable this way either.

Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier setup IWB
Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier setup IWB

Using IWB with the leather backer was more comfortable, and drawing the magazine was better. I can get it out quicker, but I must adjust how I am used to gripping the mag. This way works OK if you want maximum concealment with an appendix holster.

Wearing the Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier setup IWB
Wearing the Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier setup IWB

The IWB belt clip can be adjusted for both ride height and angle. I can also tuck my shirt in around the clip if I want. This is great when carrying concealed with dress clothes.

To change it to the OWB configuration, I removed and added the IWB clip to the OWB belt clip. I like this feature since there are times when I want to carry a spare mag both ways.

Wearing the Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier setup OWB
Wearing the Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier setup OWB

The OWB belt clip is a split loop, so I can put it on and take it off without unbuckling my belt. However, it does not attach to my belt as tight as I prefer. I can draw the mag without pulling it off my belt, which is great, but the angle of the mag carrier doesn’t stay in place. It also slides too easily. I tried it with thicker belts, and while it was better, it was still noticeable.

Recommended for:

The Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier is for anyone looking for a flexible and comfortable mag carrier. Being able to carry different mags in different positions makes this one stand out.

PROS

Flexibility

Leather IWB Backer

Tuckable IWB Clip

Adjustable Retention

CONS

OWB Clip Loose on Belt

Video on How to Setup the Crossbreed Accomplice Mag Carrier


Falco Leather Single Magazine Pouch

Falco Leather Single Magazine Pouch
  • Type: IWB or OWB
  • Material: Leather
  • Sizes: Custom-made for hundreds of gun models
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $49.95 – $69.95

The Falco Leather Single Magazine pouch is a single magazine leather pouch that can be used either IWB or OWB.

Two things stand out to me on this mag pouch.

Falco Leather Single Magazine Pouch
The Falco Leather Single Magazine Pouch

The first is the high-quality leather. I have noticed all of Falco’s Italian leather to be top-notch. They put a finish on it that both protects it and makes it look great.

The second is the adjustable retention. While not an amazing feature in itself, I usually don’t see leather mag pouches with adjustable retention. On one side of the mag pouch, they included an adjustment screw that works just like the ones on Kydex mag pouches.

On the pouch’s front is a belt clip for IWB carry. On the pouch’s back is a belt loop for OWB carry. Both stay in place, so I don’t have to change anything to switch between positions. As you have seen, most of the other IWB/OWB require some sort of changeover.

Jason wearing the Falco Leather Single Magazine Pouch
Jason wearing the Falco Leather Single Magazine Pouch

There are a ton of options available on this pouch, much like the other Falco products. I can get different leather colors, stitching colors, edge colors, embossing, and many other options.

The only thing I don’t like about this holster is it is not super comfortable when worn IWB. The edges of the belt loop stand out somewhat against my body. An undershirt helps some, but I can still feel it after wearing it for a while. I expect the leather to soften over time, though.

Recommended for:

The Falco Leather Single Magazine pouch is for anyone who wants a single leather magazine pouch with adjustable retention and no changeover between IWB and OWB.

PROS

High-Quality Leather

No Changeover Between IWB and OWB

Adjustable Retention

CONS

IWB not as Comfortable as Others

Price


1791 Gunleather Snag Mag

1791 Gunleather Snag Mag

Save 15% with code “SS15” at checkout at 1791 Gunleather!

  • Type: Pocket
  • Material: Polymer
  • Sizes: Over 50 gun models
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $21.99

The 1791 Gunleather Snag Mag is a unique device that allows me to carry a backup magazine concealed.

While I do not recommend using this as your only mag pouch, it is a great way to carry a third magazine without using a double mag pouch. If your handgun has a low capacity, this is a great option.

1791 Gunleather Snag Mag
The 1791 Gunleather Snag Mag

My magazine fits down into the snag mag, and when viewed from the back, it looks like a pocketknife with a pocket clip. The clip keeps my magazine at my pocket’s top and back edge. This allows me to use my pocket for other things still and protects my mag from pocket debris or other items.

On the side of the snag mag, a small hook sticks out and catches the inside of my pocket. This feature keeps the snag mag in my pocket when I grab the magazine and pull it.

Jason Wearing the 1791 Gunleather Snag Mag
Wearing the 1791 Gunleather Snag Mag

My only issue with it is that it doesn’t work well with some pants. Jeans seem to be OK, but pants with pockets with more of an angle don’t work as well. The hook does not catch inside my pocket when I draw the mag, so the snag mag comes out with it.

Before heading anywhere with the snag mag, I highly recommend checking to make sure it works with the pants you are wearing!

Recommended for:

The 1791 Gunleather Snag Mag is for anyone who wants to be able to carry a third magazine in their pocket.

PROS

Concealable

Good for 3rd Mag

Keeps Mag at Top of Pocket

CONS

Doesn’t Work with All Pants


Best Double Mag Pouches

Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier

Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier
  • Type: IWB or OWB
  • Material: Polymer
  • Sizes: Double Stack, Single Stack, P365, Shield, Hellcat
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $39.95

The Stealth Gear Ultralite Double Mag Carrier is a compact double mag carrier that can be worn IWB or OWB.

Stealth Gear makes unique hybrid-design holsters and is our favorite OWB holster for concealed carry.

Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup OWB with magazines
The Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup OWB with magazines

Their mag carriers follow suit. However, I like their Ultralite line since they are compact and weigh almost nothing.

The backing is a foam-type rubber, and the front mag shells are made from a polymer.

The Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup OWB with the included hardware
The Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup OWB with the included hardware

Magazine retention is adjustable with four screws, so I can set them just how I want.

I like the clips on this pouch, both the OWB and IWB styles. The OWB clips are the same as the ones on their holsters, and I can take them off easily without unbuckling my belt. They are also adjustable, so I can change the ride height and angle if I want.

Jason wearing the Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup OWB
Wearing the Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup OWB

The IWB clips are also adjustable, and I can tuck my shirt in behind them for maximum concealment when wearing dress clothes.

The Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup IWB with the included hardware
The Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup IWB with the included hardware

The backing is flexible, so the pouch conforms to my body. This makes it surprisingly concealable under just a T-shirt, and I am carrying two mags!

Jason wearing the Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup IWB
Wearing the Stealth Gear Ultralite Mag Carrier setup IWB

The only negative I have found is the backing tends to get irritating when I wear it IWB without an undershirt. Since this pouch conceals so well, I almost never wear it IWB anyway.

Recommended for:

The Stealth Gear Ultralite Double Mag Carrier is for anyone seeking a very concealable double Mag carrier.

PROS

Flexible Design

Adjustable

Good Belt Clips

CONS

IWB Wear Needs Undershirt


Craft Leather Double Magazine Pouch

Craft Leather Double Magazine Pouch
  • Type: OWB
  • Material: Leather
  • Sizes: Double Stack only
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $35.00

The Craft Leather Double Magazine pouch is a low-profile leather pouch that will carry two mags.

I really like how low-profile this mag pouch is. It is the flattest of all the mag pouches I have found, even single ones.

The Craft Leather Double Magazine Pouch
The Craft Leather Double Magazine Pouch

The design of a single piece of leather folded up with Kydex holster-type retention adjustment screws in the middle is ingenious. I often find simple designs the best, and this pouch is a great example.

On the back is a simple belt loop, which helps keep the pouch compact and close to my body. The loop is about two inches wide, so it stays in place and is very stable on my belt. The only negative with the loop is I have to unbuckle my belt to take the pouch off.

My mags fit a little tight initially, but they loosened up after leaving them in the pouch for a few days. I then adjusted the middle retention screws to get it how I wanted.

Jason Wearing the Craft Leather Double Magazine Pouch
Wearing the Craft Leather Double Magazine Pouch

The only real negative of this holster is it only comes in one size. It will not work for smaller magazines like the P365 or Glock 43 but works great for double-stack mags with 15-round capacity.

Recommended for:

The Craft Leather Double Magazine pouch is for anyone seeking a concealable leather double mag pouch.

PROS

Low Profile

Adjustable Retention

High-Quality Leather

CONS

Only for Double Stack Mags


1791 Gunleather Double Magazine Carrier

1791 Gunleather Double Magazine Carrier

Save 15% with code “SS15” at checkout at 1791 Gunleather!

  • Type: OWB
  • Material: Leather
  • Sizes: Single Stack or Double Stack
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $44.99

The 1791 Gunleather Double Mag Carrier is a full leather double mag pouch.

The leather this mag carrier is made from is no different than all the other 1791 gunleather holsters. It is amazing. It is soft yet sturdy and made from 100% American steer hide. It smells just like a new baseball glove.

The 1791 Gunleather Double Magazine Carrier
The 1791 Gunleather Double Magazine Carrier

The center of the mag pouch has adjustable screws, just like I normally see on Kydex holsters. They allow me to set the magazine retention just like I want.

The belt loops are made into the end of the holster instead of the back. This makes the overall width of the holster a little wide, but at the same time, it helps to keep it close to my body. I tighten my belt, and it pulls it right in. This is great not only for concealment but for comfort as well.

Jason wearing the 1791 Gunleather Double Magazine Carrier
Wearing the 1791 Gunleather Double Magazine Carrier

There are three sizes available, two for 1911 style single and double stack mags, and a third for polymer and metal style double stack mags (which is what I have.)

The only negative is my 15-round magazines sit a little deeper than I prefer. 17 round mags or mags with a larger base plate on them work great.

Recommended for:

The 1791 Gunleather Double Mag Carrier is for anyone looking for an all-leather mag pouch that conceals well.

PROS

Quality Leather

Adjustable Retention

Flexible Design

CONS

Short Mags Sit Deep


Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch

Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch
  • Type: OWB or IWB
  • Material: Hybrid – Leather and Kydex
  • Sizes: Custom-made for hundreds of gun models
  • Warranty: Lifetime
  • MSRP: $99.95

The Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch is a hybrid design with a leather backing and a Kydex shell.

Usually, I find that Kydex double mag pouches are too wide to be comfortable and concealable. Falco has thought of this and made this pouch curved to hug my body. This keeps it tucked in tight and surprisingly concealable under just a shirt.

The Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch
The Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch

The center of the pouch has two retention adjustment screws, and the Kydex is custom molded for the exact magazines I specify. This makes the retention of this pouch better than most others.

The belt loops are a full polymer loop on the back. They are not my favorite since I have to unbuckle my belt to remove it.

Jason wearing the Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch
Wearing the Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch

The belt clips must be changed to go from OWB to IWB. I like the IWB clips and can tuck my shirt in behind them.

Neither of the clips is adjustable, which was a little disappointing.

Overall, the quality of this mag pouch is top-notch, from the leather to the Kydex. It looks great and feels like it will last forever. However, the price is a little high, even though it is super nice.

Keep in mind this mag pouch goes well with the Falco Compact Hybrid IWB holster that we included as one of the Best IWB holsters.

The Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch with the matching holster
The Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch with the matching holster

Recommended for:

The Falco Hybrid Double Magazine Pouch is for anyone looking for a premium hybrid double magazine pouch.

PROS

Premium Quality

Adjustable Retention

Curved Design

CONS

OWB Belt Clips

Price


Reasons for Carrying a Spare Pistol Magazine Pouch

Is carrying a spare magazine for my concealed-carry handgun really that important?

We know from our list of concealed carry responsibilities that drawing our handgun on a threat is only done when we have no other choice. At this point, either our life or someone else’s is in danger. So, we need a handgun that is fully functional.

Handguns are mechanical devices that can malfunction. Magazines and ammo are integral to concealed carry handguns and can fail just the same.

Here are some reasons why carrying at least one extra magazine is necessary for concealed carry.

1. Magazine/Feed Malfunction

Magazines are simple devices with a spring that pushes the ammo cartridges up and into the feeding mechanism of the handgun. If the spring breaks or encounters debris that prevents it from pushing cartridges, my gun will no longer function.

If I have a spare magazine, I can quickly replace the malfunctioning magazine. This gets my handgun back in operation again.

2. Ammo Malfunction

Normally, I do not have any issues with ammunition. But, occasionally, I have had some with misshapen bullets or case issues. At my first state championship match, I had one that jammed up my handgun really hard.

It took me a few seconds to clear it, and since I didn’t know if it was the ammo or the magazine I changed to my spare magazine. I won’t have time to inspect and diagnose in a stressful situation.

So, I no longer assume that all of my ammo will perform perfectly, whether at a match or while carrying concealed.

3. Additional Capacity

While not as likely, if I am faced with multiple attackers, I may need additional ammo while trying to escape. After stopping the initial threat, I want to be able to top off my handgun with a full magazine just in case the attack continues. This is even more important on handguns with a lower capacity.

Pocket vs. Mag Pouch

While throwing an extra mag in a pocket somewhere is tempting, I do not recommend it.

First, trying to fish a magazine out of a pocket after I have drawn my handgun puts me in a vulnerable position. I have already pointed my handgun at a threat, and now I am standing there with one hand in my pocket, and my gun isn’t functional.

Not to mention I do not wear the same pants every day, and they all have different pockets in different places. This makes me slow and inefficient.

Second, pockets tend to be places where lint and debris collect. If I have anything else in my pocket, it could also become stuck in the mag. This will cause my second mag to be no better than my faulty primary.

Keep your backup mag in a dedicated mag pouch that is in the same place, no matter what you are wearing. Practice drawing the mag from that position so you can do it when stressed.


Tips for Choosing the Best Pistol Magazine Pouch

There are some key features that you should consider before purchasing a mag pouch. While it seems to be a simple choice, it could be a life-or-death decision.

Concealment

When I am carrying my handgun concealed, I usually want my spare magazine concealed as well. I look for a low-profile magazine pouch that sits as close to my body as possible while still allowing me to get a good grip on the magazine.

IWB vs OWB

When most people think of concealment, they immediately think IWB is the only way. I have found it easy to conceal an OWB mag pouch under just a shirt.

OWB Mag Pouches
Some OWB Mag Pouches

In some cases, when carrying my handgun in the appendix position, I will carry an IWB magazine pouch beside my holster. It just depends on the shirt I am wearing and the magazine size. Most of the time, I carry an OWB mag pouch on my weak side (left) hip.

Some magazine pouches can be configured for both IWB and OWB. Often, I find this is the best choice for most people since they can try them both ways.

Regardless of the way you choose, I find that it is best to stay consistent. Training emergency reloads is an important part of a defensive handgun training program, and carrying two different ways is just more to train and could be confusing in a stressful situation.

Overall, I find that OWB usually works the best since I can get a better grip on the magazine. Having to grab it and reposition my hand to load my gun risks dropping it, I have found. I need bullets in the gun, not on the floor.

Double vs Single Mag Pouch

I feel a single mag pouch is sufficient for magazine capacities over ten. If I carry a capacity lower than this, I like to have a double magazine pouch.

Another option is to have a pocket magazine holder like the Snag Mag above for a third magazine. This way, I can carry a smaller single-mag pouch on my belt and have a third mag available just in case.

Magazine Retention

My magazine pouch must retain the magazine sufficiently. I like to have them a little on the tight side so in case I am in a struggle, they do not fall out easily. Magazine pouches that have adjustable retention are the best.

Substantial Attachment Clip

The magazine pouch should attach to my belt, so a proper clip is necessary. The clip should hook under my belt so that I do not pull the pouch off when drawing the magazine.

The clip should also hold the magazine pouch on my belt so that it does not move along my belt from front to back. I want it in the same place at all times so that when the time comes, my training kicks in, and I can draw the magazine without searching for it.

Allows Full Grip of the Magazine

The magazine pouch should not entirely cover the magazine. I need to be able to grip the magazine and load it into my handgun in one fluid motion.

Jason showing getting a full grip on the magazine
Jason showing getting a full grip on the magazine

I do not want to pull and regrip the magazine as it introduces the chances of dropping it in the transition. It is also much slower and harder to do when moving or awkwardly.

Jason showing getting a full grip on the magazine out of the pouch
Jason showing getting a full grip on the magazine after drawing it from the pouch

Material

In general, I stay with two materials, Kydex and leather.

Kydex is more durable and is not susceptible to sweat and water like leather is. However, leather is more comfortable. Plus, the leather looks good.

Hybrid designs like those on our list are great for IWB carry since they have a piece of leather between my body and the holster. I find that these are the most comfortable IWB magazine pouches.

Price

I find the sweet spot for magazine pouches between $25 and $50. Less than this, and you are probably getting an inferior product made in a low-cost country, more than this, and you are probably wasting money unless you are looking for something that looks really nice.


Choose the Best Pistol Magazine Pouch for You

We found that the Alien Gear Photon Mag Carrier is the best choice for most people.

If you prefer leather, then go with the Craft Leather Single Mag Pouch.

To be able to carry two extra magazines, go with the Stealth Gear Ultralite Double Mag Carrier.

If you have not already, be sure to check our how to choose the best concealed carry holster guide as well as how to choose the best concealed carry handgun guides. We have a number of holster reviews as well, plus more coming.

Also, be sure to follow our full concealed carry guide. It is full of guides and reviews and includes info you won’t find anywhere else.

Go Back to the Concealed Carry Guide

Next: Best Concealed Carry Belts

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Photo of author
Jason has an engineering and problem solving background. He is an avid outdoorsman, survivalist, and competitive shooter. He enjoys researching the best and most practical solutions for the problem at hand, studying stoicism, and finding innovative ways to be prepared.